🔗 Share this article

This talented musician always experienced the weight of her family heritage. Being the child of the renowned Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, one of the best-known English artists of the 1900s, the composer’s identity was enveloped in the long shadows of the past.

The First Recording

Not long ago, I reflected on these shadows as I got ready to make the inaugural album of Avril’s 1936 piano concerto. With its intense musical themes, expressive melodies, and confident beats, Avril’s work will grant music lovers valuable perspective into how the composer – a composer during war born in 1903 – imagined her existence as a woman of colour.

Legacy and Reality

However about shadows. One needs patience to adjust, to perceive forms as they actually appear, to tell reality from misrepresentation, and I felt hesitant to confront Avril’s past for a while.

I deeply hoped her to be following in her father’s footsteps. Partially, she was. The pastoral English palettes of Samuel’s influence can be observed in many of her works, including From the Hills (1934) and Sussex Landscape (1940). But you only have to examine the names of her father’s compositions to realize how he identified as not only a flag bearer of English Romanticism and also a voice of the African heritage.

It was here that Samuel and Avril began to differ.

American society evaluated Samuel by the excellence of his music instead of the his ethnicity.

Samuel’s African Roots

During his studies at the Royal College of Music, her father – the offspring of a African father and a white English mother – started to lean into his African roots. At the time the poet of color the renowned Dunbar visited the UK in 1897, the young musician was keen to meet him. He adapted the poet’s African Romances to music and the subsequent year adapted his verses for a musical work, Dream Lovers. Then came the choral work that established his reputation: Hiawatha’s Wedding Feast.

Based on Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s The Song of Hiawatha, this composition was an international hit, particularly among Black Americans who felt shared pride as white America assessed his work by the excellence of his compositions rather than the his background.

Advocacy and Beliefs

Success did not temper his beliefs. In 1900, he was present at the pioneering African conference in the UK where he met the Black American thinker WEB Du Bois and saw a range of talks, such as the mistreatment of the Black community there. He was an activist to his final days. He sustained relationships with early civil rights leaders including this intellectual and this leader, spoke publicly on ending discrimination, and even engaged in dialogue on matters of race with the American leader on a trip to the White House in that year. As for his music, Du Bois recalled, “he established his reputation so high as a musician that it will endure.” He passed away in the early 20th century, at 37 years old. Yet how might Samuel have made of his offspring’s move to travel to South Africa in the that decade?

Controversy and Apartheid

“Child of Celebrated Artist shows support to apartheid system,” declared a title in the Black American publication Jet magazine. This policy “seems to me the right policy”, she informed Jet. When asked to explain, she revised her statement: she didn’t agree with the system “in principle” and it “should be allowed to resolve itself, overseen by benevolent residents of all races”. Had Avril been more attuned to her father’s politics, or raised in segregated America, she could have hesitated about the policy. But life had shielded her.

Background and Inexperience

“I have a English document,” she said, “and the officials never asked me about my ethnicity.” So, with her “fair” complexion (as described), she floated alongside white society, supported by their acclaim for her deceased parent. She presented about her father’s music at the University of Cape Town and led the broadcasting ensemble in Johannesburg, featuring the heroic third movement of her composition, subtitled: “In remembrance of my Father.” Even though a accomplished player personally, she never played as the lead performer in her work. Rather, she always led as the conductor; and so the segregated ensemble followed her lead.

She desired, as she stated, she “might bring a change”. But by 1954, things fell apart. When government agents learned of her Black ancestry, she was forced to leave the land. Her British passport failed to safeguard her, the British high commissioner urged her to go or risk imprisonment. She came home, feeling great shame as the magnitude of her naivety was realized. “The realization was a painful one,” she expressed. Adding to her humiliation was the printing that year of her ill-fated Jet interview, a year after her sudden departure from South Africa.

A Recurring Theme

As I sat with these legacies, I perceived a familiar story. The account of being British until it’s challenged – which recalls African-descended soldiers who defended the British during the global conflict and survived only to be refused rightful benefits. Along with the Windrush era,